Choosing the Right Contractor: What to Look for in a Remodeling Company

October 3, 2025

Hiring the right remodeling company can make the difference between a seamless upgrade and a stressful ordeal. With so many contractors available, narrowing your choices may seem overwhelming, but knowing what qualities to prioritize can guide you to a reliable, skilled team that respects your time, property, and budget.

Licensing, Insurance, and Credentials

Any reputable remodeling company should be fully licensed and insured. Licensing ensures that the contractor has met required standards for professionalism and technical knowledge. Insurance protects you from liability in case of property damage or on-site injuries. Don't settle for verbal confirmation—ask to see documentation and verify their credentials are current and valid.

Proven Experience and Portfolio

Established remodeling contractors have an extensive track record. Look for companies that have been in business for several years with a portfolio showcasing various types of work, such as kitchens, bathrooms, home additions, and whole-house renovations. Before-and-after photos, client testimonials, and even in-person references are all helpful indicators of a contractor’s ability to deliver quality results consistently.


In addition to portfolio depth, variety in completed projects shows adaptability. Whether your home is historic or modern, experienced remodelers should have demonstrated success with a range of architectural styles, design preferences, and structural complexities.

Clear Communication and Detailed Estimates

Professionalism is reflected in how a company communicates. Timely responses, transparency, and a willingness to answer your concerns indicate a team that values customer relationships. The right contractor will walk you through each phase of the process and make sure you fully understand your options.


Detailed written estimates are non-negotiable. Vague quotes can lead to disputes down the road. Look for itemized breakdowns that outline costs for materials, labor, permits, and timeline expectations. A contractor who is upfront about pricing helps set accurate expectations and builds trust from day one.

Strong Local Reputation

Remodeling companies with deep roots in the community often provide a more personal, responsive service. Online reviews, word-of-mouth referrals, and community involvement all reflect a contractor's reputation. Choose a team with consistent praise for reliability, craftsmanship, and respectful service.


It’s also wise to consider how disputes or changes were handled. A well-reviewed contractor will have a proven record of resolving issues professionally, without sacrificing quality or creating conflict with homeowners.

Commitment to Cleanliness and Jobsite Safety

A remodeling company’s respect for your property is evident in how they maintain the jobsite. Professional contractors take steps to minimize disruption, dust, and mess. Look for companies that provide daily cleanup and use protective materials to safeguard furniture, flooring, and other surfaces.


Equally important is how the company manages safety. Jobsite protocols should prioritize worker safety, protect your household, and follow building codes. A clean, organized workspace is a clear sign of professionalism and attention to detail.


At Shafer Construction, LLC, we bring over 19 years of experience to homes and businesses across Youngstown, Ohio. We know that remodeling is a major investment, and we treat each project with precision, respect, and dedication. When you choose our team, you're not just hiring contractors—you’re partnering with a company that values craftsmanship, honesty, and peace of mind. Let’s make your next remodel smooth, beautiful, and stress-free—contact us today.

Green house with a door and windows, pink rose bush, and green lawn.
September 4, 2025
When planning a home renovation, energy efficiency should be a top priority. Not only do energy-efficient upgrades reduce your utility bills, but they also increase the value of your home and contribute to a more sustainable environment.
Close-up of a house roof with gray shingles, a small dormer window, and a blue sky with fluffy
cloud
August 11, 2025
Your roof is one of the most important structural elements of your home. It takes the brunt of rain, wind, heat, and cold, day after day, year after year. Over time, all that exposure adds up. Cracks can form, shingles can loosen, and small leaks can quietly develop into expensive problems.
A kitchen with wooden cabinets , granite counter tops , a sink and a window.
July 11, 2025
Planning a kitchen remodel is more than choosing paint colors and new appliances. It’s a complete process that starts with a solid vision and ends with a beautiful, functional space tailored to your daily life.
A wooden deck with stairs leading up to it and a white railing.
June 4, 2025
Your deck should feel like an extension of your home—a place to relax, entertain, or simply enjoy a warm breeze. A well-designed deck can enhance curb appeal, increase your home’s value, and create an outdoor escape that feels both inviting and intentional.
A long hallway with a wooden table in the middle of it.
May 12, 2025
Adding onto your home can solve space issues, boost property value, and allow you to stay in the neighborhood you love. But planning a home addition isn’t something you can wing. It takes careful thought, budgeting, and coordination to pull it off successfully.
A white house with black windows and a wooden fence in front of it.
April 21, 2025
Curb appeal plays a key role in a home's overall value. One of the most impactful ways to improve it is by upgrading the siding. As siding ages, it can fade, crack, or warp, making even a well-maintained property appear outdated.
An empty basement with a wooden floor and stairs.
March 19, 2025
When it comes to home improvement, your basement holds incredible untapped potential. At Shafer Construction, LLC, we specialize in transforming underutilized basements into functional, stylish, and comfortable living spaces.
February 27, 2025
Your bathroom is more than just a functional space—it’s a personal sanctuary. As we step into 2025, new trends in bathroom remodeling are emerging, blending luxury, sustainability, and smart technology to create the ultimate relaxation haven.